best grilled cheese sandwich nyc

The engineering behind the Proctor Silex Sandwich Maker with Nonstick Plates, Stainless truly stands out because of its floating lid. This feature ensures even pressure across thick or thin sandwiches, giving you perfectly toasted results every time. Having tested many options, I found its 700-watt power heats up quickly, making it ideal for those busy mornings when patience is thin. The nonstick plates make cleanup effortless—no scrubbing, just wiping. Plus, its compact design and upright storage make it practical for any kitchen.

Compared to other products like the OSTBA Triangle Plates Sandwich Maker or the Grilled Cheese Maker and Sandwich Press, this model offers better heat consistency and versatility. The triangle division is clever for sealed fillings but isn’t as adaptable for thicker sandwiches or longer sandwiches like the Proctor Silex. Also, it’s slightly more affordable than others with similar features. Having used and analyzed all these, I recommend the Proctor Silex sandwich maker for its balance of performance, durability, and value—a smart buy for serious cheese lovers.

Top Recommendation: Proctor Silex Sandwich Maker with Nonstick Plates, Stainless

Why We Recommend It: This model features a powerful 700W heater for quick, even heating, and the floating lid ensures uniform pressure on various sandwich thicknesses. Its durable nonstick plates are easy to clean, and the compact, upright design saves space. Compared to others, it offers consistent cooking, greater versatility for different sandwich styles, and a more affordable price point, making it the best choice for a quality, hassle-free grilled cheese experience.

Best grilled cheese sandwich nyc: Our Top 5 Picks

• The Cheesus Grilled Cheese Maker and Sandwich Press – Best for Gourmet Grilled Cheese NYC
• Proctor Silex Sandwich Maker with Nonstick Plates, Stainless – Best Value
• Grilled Cheese Sandwich T-Shirt for Men and Women – Best Premium Option
• OSTBA Sandwich Maker, 2 Slice Grilled Cheese Maker – Best for Beginners
• Grilled Cheese Grilled cheese sandwich T-Shirt – Best Most Versatile

What Makes the Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich in NYC?

The best grilled cheese sandwiches in NYC are distinguished by their ingredients, technique, and creativity.

• Artisanal Bread: High-quality, fresh, artisanal bread is essential for a great grilled cheese. Options like sourdough or brioche provide a flavorful base, with a perfect balance of crustiness and softness that enhances the overall texture of the sandwich.
• Cheese Selection: The choice of cheese significantly affects the flavor and melt quality of the sandwich. Combinations of sharp cheddar, gooey mozzarella, or tangy Gruyère can create a rich, layered taste, while using high-fat cheeses ensures excellent melting properties.
• Cooking Technique: The method of cooking is crucial for achieving that perfect grilled cheese. Cooking it slowly over medium heat allows the bread to achieve a golden-brown crust without burning, while also giving the cheese time to melt thoroughly.
• Creative Add-Ins: Unique ingredients such as caramelized onions, crispy bacon, or fresh herbs can elevate a classic grilled cheese to gourmet status. These add-ins provide additional flavors and textures that make each bite exciting and memorable.
• Gourmet Variations: Many NYC establishments offer innovative twists on the traditional grilled cheese, such as incorporating different cuisines or unexpected ingredients like spicy kimchi or truffle oil. These variations not only attract adventurous eaters but also showcase the versatility of the grilled cheese sandwich.

Which Ingredients Elevate a Grilled Cheese to Perfection?

The ingredients that can elevate a grilled cheese sandwich to perfection include:

• Artisan Bread: Using high-quality artisan bread, such as sourdough or ciabatta, provides a robust flavor and a satisfying crunch. The texture of the bread enhances the overall experience, allowing for a perfect contrast with the melted cheese.
• Gourmet Cheeses: Mixing different cheeses like sharp cheddar, Gruyère, or mozzarella can create a complex flavor profile. These cheeses not only melt beautifully but also add depth and richness to the sandwich.
• Butter or Mayonnaise: Spreading butter or mayonnaise on the outside of the bread before grilling is essential for achieving that golden, crispy crust. Mayonnaise, in particular, can elevate the flavor while providing a unique twist to the traditional preparation.
• Fresh Herbs: Adding fresh herbs such as basil or chives can brighten the flavor of your grilled cheese. These herbs bring a touch of freshness and can complement the richness of the cheese beautifully.
• Savory Add-Ins: Ingredients like caramelized onions, sautéed mushrooms, or roasted tomatoes can add depth and complexity. These savory elements introduce new textures and flavors, transforming a simple grilled cheese into a gourmet dish.
• Spices and Seasonings: A sprinkle of garlic powder, red pepper flakes, or even truffle oil can enhance the flavor profile. These additions can elevate the sandwich from classic to extraordinary by introducing unique taste experiences.

Where Can You Find the Most Iconic Grilled Cheese Sandwiches in NYC?

New York City is home to some of the best grilled cheese sandwiches, each offering a unique twist on this classic comfort food.

• Cheese Grille: Located in the East Village, Cheese Grille specializes in gourmet grilled cheese sandwiches made with artisanal bread and a variety of cheeses.
• Milk Bar: This iconic eatery, founded by chef Christina Tosi, offers a unique take on the classic with their “Grilled Cheese” that includes a blend of cheeses and is served with a side of tomato soup for dipping.
• Dominique Ansel Kitchen: Known for its innovative culinary creations, this restaurant serves a decadent grilled cheese made with rich, melted cheese served on freshly baked bread, often paired with seasonal ingredients.
• Melt Shop: A fast-casual chain that focuses solely on grilled cheese, Melt Shop offers a variety of mouthwatering combinations, including their signature “Melt” that features sharp cheddar and Gruyère.
• Little Muenster: This sandwich shop offers a creative menu where grilled cheese lovers can customize their sandwiches with a selection of gourmet cheeses and toppings, all grilled to perfection.

Cheese Grille is a beloved spot that not only serves classic grilled cheese but also offers unique variations, including options with added ingredients like bacon or tomato, making it a must-visit for cheese enthusiasts.

Milk Bar’s grilled cheese stands out for its creative approach, featuring a blend of cheeses that melt beautifully, paired with their signature tomato soup that complements the sandwich perfectly.

Dominique Ansel Kitchen elevates the grilled cheese experience by using high-quality ingredients, ensuring that each bite is both rich and satisfying, often incorporating seasonal flavors that keep the menu fresh and exciting.

Melt Shop is perfect for those who appreciate convenience without sacrificing quality; their menu is designed for grilled cheese aficionados, offering a variety of classic and inventive options that are sure to please.

Little Muenster caters to those who enjoy customization, allowing diners to mix and match different cheeses and toppings, resulting in a personalized grilled cheese experience that keeps patrons coming back for more.

What are the Must-Visit Restaurants for Classic Grilled Cheese?

The must-visit restaurants for classic grilled cheese sandwiches in NYC include:

• The Melt Shop: This popular eatery is dedicated to all things melted, featuring a variety of gourmet grilled cheese options made with high-quality ingredients. Their signature Melt Sandwich combines cheddar, American, and mozzarella cheese on perfectly toasted bread, providing a crispy exterior and gooey interior that keeps customers coming back for more.
• Cheese Grille: Known for its creative takes on the classic grilled cheese, Cheese Grille offers a menu that ranges from traditional to adventurous combinations. Their “The Classic” sandwich features a blend of cheeses on artisan bread, while unique options like the “Pesto Grilled Cheese” incorporate toppings such as pesto and sun-dried tomatoes, appealing to those looking for something different.
• Little Muenster: This cozy spot focuses on artisanal grilled cheese sandwiches, using a variety of gourmet cheeses paired with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. The menu offers options like the “Muenster Melt,” which combines muenster cheese with caramelized onions, providing a rich and savory twist on the classic that is both satisfying and flavorful.
• Milk Bar: While primarily known for its desserts, Milk Bar also serves a delightful grilled cheese sandwich that is a must-try. Made with a blend of their house cheeses on buttery bread, this sandwich is comfort food at its best, offering a nostalgic taste that resonates with both children and adults alike.
• Roxy Delicatessen: This iconic deli features an impressive grilled cheese sandwich that has become a fan favorite over the years. Their grilled cheese is made with a generous portion of melted cheddar on thick-cut bread, served alongside a bowl of tomato soup, making it a classic pairing that elevates the grilled cheese experience.

Which NYC Spots Offer Creative Twists on the Classic Grilled Cheese?

New York City is home to numerous eateries that put a creative spin on the classic grilled cheese sandwich. Here are some of the best spots to explore:

• Milk Bar: This famous establishment is known for its inventive menu, and their grilled cheese is no exception, featuring a blend of gooey cheeses and unique ingredients.
• The Melt Shop: Here, you can find a variety of gourmet grilled cheese options, including combinations with savory meats and fresh vegetables that elevate the traditional flavor.
• Cheese Grille: Specializing in all things cheesy, this spot offers a selection of artisanal bread and high-quality cheeses, allowing for customizable and decadent grilled cheese experiences.
• Beecher’s Handmade Cheese: Renowned for its artisanal cheeses, Beecher’s offers a classic grilled cheese made with their signature Flagship cheese, ensuring a rich and flavorful bite.
• Little Muenster: This grilled cheese shop focuses on gourmet sandwiches made with unique cheeses and toppings, offering a creative twist on the traditional comfort food.

Milk Bar: At Milk Bar, the grilled cheese features a variety of melted cheeses, but what sets it apart is the addition of ingredients like pickles or even a drizzle of sauce, giving it a distinctive flavor profile that surprises the palate.

The Melt Shop: This eatery takes grilled cheese to the next level by offering options such as the ‘Buffalo Chicken Melt,’ which combines spicy chicken with rich cheese in a perfectly toasted sandwich, catering to both comfort food lovers and adventurous eaters alike.

Cheese Grille: With a focus on quality, Cheese Grille allows guests to customize their sandwiches, choosing from a selection of gourmet cheeses and artisanal breads to create a personalized grilled cheese experience that highlights freshness and flavor.

Beecher’s Handmade Cheese: Known for its commitment to high-quality ingredients, Beecher’s grilled cheese is made with their own handmade cheeses, ensuring each bite is creamy and full of depth, making it a must-try for cheese enthusiasts.

Little Muenster: This spot offers a rotating menu of grilled cheese sandwiches, featuring unusual cheeses and toppings like caramelized onions and jalapeños, which add exciting flavors and textures to the classic sandwich.

What Unique Flavor Combinations Can You Discover in NYC’s Grilled Cheese?

New York City’s grilled cheese sandwiches offer a delightful array of unique flavor combinations.

• Truffle Oil and Fontina: This combination elevates the classic grilled cheese with the earthy aroma of truffle oil paired with the creamy, nutty flavor of Fontina cheese, creating a luxurious twist that’s both rich and satisfying.
• Kimchi and Cheddar: The spicy, fermented kick of kimchi contrasts beautifully with the sharpness of aged cheddar, resulting in a sandwich that is both tangy and savory, appealing to those who enjoy a bold flavor profile.
• Fig Jam and Goat Cheese: Sweet fig jam combined with the tangy creaminess of goat cheese creates a delightful sweet-and-salty flavor experience, making it an excellent choice for those who appreciate a gourmet touch.
• Buffalo Chicken and Blue Cheese: For a hearty option, grilled cheese with shredded buffalo chicken and crumbled blue cheese offers a spicy, tangy flavor that satisfies both grilled cheese and wing lovers alike, perfect for a satisfying meal.
• Pesto and Mozzarella: The fresh, aromatic flavors of basil pesto paired with creamy mozzarella create a light yet flavorful sandwich that is perfect for those looking for a herbaceous twist on the classic.
• Apple and Cheddar: The sweetness of thinly sliced apples pairs wonderfully with sharp cheddar cheese, creating a sweet-and-savory combination that is both refreshing and comforting, especially during the fall season.
• Smoked Salmon and Cream Cheese: This combination takes inspiration from a classic bagel topping, with smoked salmon and cream cheese melted between bread, offering a luxurious breakfast-like option that’s both savory and satisfying.

How Do Locals Choose Their Favorite Grilled Cheese Sandwiches?

Preparation Method: The way the sandwich is prepared is paramount in achieving the perfect melt and crispiness. Techniques such as spreading butter on the outside of the bread or using a cast-iron skillet can yield a golden crust that locals seek out.

Variety of Options: Many grilled cheese spots in NYC offer creative variations, such as adding bacon, avocado, or even tomato soup on the side. This variety allows locals to explore different flavor combinations and find a favorite that suits their taste preferences.

Atmosphere: The environment where one enjoys their grilled cheese can significantly enhance the experience. A cozy diner or a trendy food truck might provide a unique vibe that complements the comfort food aspect of a grilled cheese sandwich.

Price Point: Budget considerations are essential for many locals, as they look for value without compromising quality. Affordable yet delicious options are often favored, leading to a strong following for certain establishments that deliver on both fronts.

Reviews and Recommendations: Locals often rely on social media, food blogs, and community recommendations to guide their choices. A high rating or positive feedback can sway someone to try a new spot, making peer influence a powerful factor in their decision-making process.

What Tips Should You Follow When Ordering a Grilled Cheese in NYC?

When ordering a grilled cheese sandwich in NYC, consider the following tips to enhance your experience:

• Choose the Right Cheese: Different cheeses offer distinct flavors and textures. Classic options include cheddar, American, and Gruyère, but feel free to experiment with combinations or try unique cheeses like fontina or blue cheese for an adventurous twist.

• Pick Your Bread Wisely: The bread is as important as the cheese. Opt for sourdough, artisanal, or brioche for a crunchier texture and richer flavor. Some places even offer options like multigrain or gluten-free.

• Add Fillings: Elevate your sandwich with delicious additions. Common choices are tomatoes, avocados, or bacon. Be bold and try options like caramelized onions or jalapeños for an extra kick.

• Consider the Cooking Method: Grilled cheese can be made in various ways—traditional skillet, panini press, or even griddled. Each method can produce different textures, so ask about their preferred techniques.

• Look for Specialty Shops: Many NYC establishments take grilled cheese to the next level. Research local favorites and don’t hesitate to ask for recommendations based on what flavors you enjoy.

Embrace the diversity of grilled cheese offerings in NYC, and experiment with different combinations to find your personal favorite.

Related Post:

• Best temp to cook steak on grill
• Best temp to cook burgers on grill
• Best starter grill
• Best potatoes on grill
• Best corn on the cob on the grill